When’s the last time someone referred to Kim and Kelly of the Breeders as “The Real Deal?”
Can we do that here? Because I’m practically a professional reviewer of nostalgia acts at this point, but the Breeders, more than any other revival act I’ve seen in the past several months, actually seem like a real band. Or as much like a real band as they ever did, anyway.
Last night, the Deal sisters and bandmates handed their packed, loyal, mostly aging crowd a 23-song show at First Avenue that was marked by, well, some modicum of real Deal-ness. The low-energy but competent performance gave almost equal time to their latest record, All Nerve, as it did their best known hits of their alternative heyday.
But here’s the risk you take: Getting the good of the Breeders means accepting the bad of the Breeders. Yes, their great new album is a compelling argument for why they transcend ’90s Gen-X reunion-act status better than many of their peers. (Maybe even including the Pixies.)
But that doesn’t excuse a two-decade plus habit of quietly farting around between songs that superfans might find charming but feels like slow momentum-killing torture for the rest of us, as if Kim wanted everyone to be uncomfortably aware of how hot and stinky the Mainroom floor was.
Still, when the band was playing, they played, charging through new and old, if not always hitting on all cylinders. “Cannonball” was surprisingly downplayed, almost demure, as if the band didn’t want to put too much effort into their breakthrough hit. “Gigantic,” unsurprisingly, was better than when the Pixies play “Gigantic.” (You win that one too, Kim.)
The Breeders have never been the most precise band, and there were moments of slop. But they were tighter than they were 25 years ago. (Let’s assume healthier living has something to do with that). And their new material probably drew their best performances from them, as if they were saying, “Look, we’re still a real band. We’re actually releasing music. We don’t give as much of a shit about 25 years ago as we did then, and you shouldn’t either.”
Wait in the Car
Howl at the Summit
Drivin' on 9 (Ed's Redeeming Qualities cover)
Walking with a Killer
I Just Wanna Get Along
Happiness Is a Warm Gun (Beatles cover)
Gigantic (Pixies cover)
Do You Love Me Now?